Refer a friend and receive up to £1,000!  

Why bosses can’t control their emotions and overpay at auctions

This week’s column by Luke Johnson in the Sunday Times focuses on the intricacies of buying or selling a business.  As always, we think it’s a beautifully written and thought-provoking piece; if you’d like to discuss it with us, feel free to drop us an email or call us on 020 8530 0720.

 

Why are auction prices so often set by buyers who overbid? This question holds significance for purchasers of companies — which are usually auctioned. While there is no exact science to valuing businesses, I would say that “winners” of auctions often pay too much.

Psychologists suggest that people overbid because of a powerful fear of losing. Normally rational business executives can suffer from an emotional state, termed “competitive arousal”, fuelled by adrenaline. Instead of deciding to buy an asset based on logical analysis, the goal mutates, and becomes all about beating an opponent. In such circumstances, the successful bidder can end up burdened with the winner’s curse — lasting regret over the excessive price paid.

The classic case was the mad acquisition of ABN Amro by Royal Bank of Scotland, Fortis and Santander in 2007. The joint bidders caught auction fever after Barclays tried to gatecrash their deal. Subsequently, both RBS and Fortis needed government bailouts — RBS alone lost £20bn on the transaction. The board were disgraced, shareholders lost 95% of their investment, and the taxpayer had to inject almost £40bn into the banking sector to prevent collapse.

Advisers who orchestrate auctions make sure there is a tight timetable in order to maximise competitive tension. This can help tempt bidders to overpay. Deadlines are designed to put pressure on participants. Interestingly, research suggests that competitive spirits are most ferocious when bidders face only one serious rival. I suspect this is because bidders think they have better odds of triumphing in such circumstances.

We have sold four companies for decent prices this year. Easily the best price came from an auction that ended up with two very keen rival bidders.

There is a delicate game played by bankers acting for sellers. In my experience, they will not knowingly lie to would-be purchasers about the existence and level of rival bids, but they will desperately try to maintain the asymmetric level of information between the selling and buying parties. This issue is relevant only in disposals of private businesses, since bids must be disclosed in disposals of public companies. Of course, the fact that public-company bids are carried out under the bright spotlight of media coverage means competitive excitement can be even more intense. No one wants to lose publicly.

Moreover, bidders can justify to themselves paying whatever it takes because of sunk costs, in terms of time and fees. Of course, this is usually a terrible reason to pay more. Advisers generally earn far more from the winning bidder — yet face no negative consequences if their client overpays. So, inevitably, they will encourage a bidding frenzy, working up ever more ludicrous rationalisations to support higher prices.

This applies to the lawyers and accountants as much as the bankers. They can fuel the overconfidence of a bidder, allowing them to think they understand the target better than they do. The professional who should stay sober, independent and aloof from the fray is perversely incentivised to see a deal happen at almost any cost to their client. Commitment escalates as the auction wears on, until bidders risk losing all perspective and paying a price they would never have contemplated at the outset.

Most buyers who overbid are not paying with their own money. Either they are managers using corporate cash or, in the case of private equity, partners whose funding comes from banks and outside investors. Humans are far more cautious about risking their personal resources. I tend to spend mainly my own cash when buying companies — and so I frequently lose out in auctions. Of course, I can get carried away, and I have certainly overpaid for businesses. However, paying more than you should, simply because someone else is willing to fork out a higher price, is a stupid idea. Other bidders may be fools or enjoy merger synergies unavailable to you. You should set your own price limits and stick to them.

Wild prices have become standard in the past 10 years because of ultra-low interest rates, quantitative easing and a financial system awash with liquidity. Thanks to luck or smarts, bidders with big balls have paid silly prices only to see asset prices rise even further. I cannot believe that trend will continue.

Luke Johnson is chairman of Risk Capital Partners and the Institute of Cancer Research.

If you’re thinking about selling your business – or buying a new one, we’d love to chat with you about your options.  Call us on 020 8530 0720 or email paula.w@nordens.co.uk.

You can read the original article here.

Beyond Accountancy

At Nordens we're more than just accountants, we're business experts who can help you achieve the biggest goals.

Our specialist strategic division at Norden’s boasts some of the leading entrepreneurial business minds in the country. They cater towards delivering consistent success stories for businesses looking to achieve all their goals and more.

Through highly tailored guidance, coaching and advice, Norden’s Strategic are able to define exactly how your business can attain new levels of success.

Regardless of how you define ‘success’ for your business, our strategic service is guaranteed to bring about real and lasting change. By partnering with some of the UK’s top business coaches, we steer you along the path to greater future.

Every business, no matter how big or small, needs to make the right decisions. How to best manage your accounts can put huge question marks over your business. Accounting 2 You are here to take that away and provide all the answers you need.

Our bookkeeping branch offers a fully inclusive, comprehensive service that they can trust. Since 2005, our specialist bookkeepers have been successfully managing the accounting of individuals and small businesses.

With experts in payroll analysis, credit control and financial recording, Accounting 2 You will lead your business efficiently and with a real purpose to help you grow and prosper.

Voted as EXCELLENT - 9.9 out of 10 based on 164 reviews

<
Chris Dyer

Director - Metro Bank

Nordens are always very easy to deal with and extremely professional and efficient. I would have no hesitation in recommending them to my clients for their accountancy needs, no matter how complex they may be.

Read more reviews on Trust Pilot

Jamie Brown

Co-Founder - Chicmi Limited

Very good to work with - the team go above and beyond to make the accounts easy and efficient. They're all super friendly and a joy to work with.

Read more reviews on Trust Pilot

Simon Rose

Director - Rose Opticians

I have been using Norden Chartered Accountants for 5 years and very happy with the service provided. All members of the team are very knowledgeable and have a wealth of experience which has proved very beneficial to my organisation

Read more reviews on Trust Pilot

Rebecca Bossick

Founder & Director - Physio LDN

Very easy to contact and put me in touch with the right person whenever I need to ask any questions. Extremely knowledgeable and can help me manage my various businesses whenever I need.

Read more reviews on Trust Pilot

James Aconley

Principal - Pauline Quirke Academy

Great accountants, always available to offer advice. The team have transformed my business.

Read more reviews on Trust Pilot

Christopher Wilce

Founder - Dataphone

Having worked with Nordens over the last 5 years, not only to look after my annual accounts but they have also provided outstanding professional advice. They have guided me through a Company share buyback with clear and objective advice. We have also been using Nordens strategic services for a couple of years, which has helped bring about significant improvements that exceeded my expectations. With experience of working with several local accountants over my 29 years in business, I’m very pleased with the service I have received from Nordens.

Read more reviews on Trust Pilot

Dave Hodges

Director - Linekers

Trusted our business with Nordens for over 10 years now and watched the company grow into the successful innovative business it has become today. Deservedly so. Every aspect of financial advice we need is always given promptly and with a smile. We have total confidence in all aspects of advice Nordens give. If you are looking for accountants, its a no brainer!

Read more reviews on Trust Pilot

Tony Charles

Founder - Foundation Sports Limited

A fantastic, modern, vibrant firm that care about the clients and their staff in abundance. It is rare to find an Accountancy firm with such vibrance and focus and relationships. It is no wonder they win award after award in their field.

Read more reviews on Trust Pilot

Peter Horlock

Managing Director - Prime Time Boilers

I have been with Nordens for many years now and they are a great accountants.

Read more reviews on Trust Pilot

Simon Cushing

Founder - Vivid Finishes

We have used Nordens for the last 5 years and have had a great service throughout. The guys are very passionate about what they do and have played a part in the growth of our company, highly recommended.

Read more reviews on Trust Pilot

Andrew Martin

Managing Director - AMD Interior Architecture

Great Service at Nordens from a friendly very approachable team Particularly Kirsty Willis and Joe Sword who have been helping us since we started the business in 2016.

Read more reviews on Trust Pilot

James Robinson

Director - Forma London

Nordens provide a first class service. We moved to Nordens last year and have been impressed with the level of service provided. Keep up the good work!

Read more reviews on Trust Pilot

>
Latest News

We've always got our ears to the ground when it comes to interesting, useful and topical information relating to business and accountancy.

Sole Traders Often Struggle…
Taking the leap into self-employment is a popular step for many entrepreneurial people, but the realities of running your own business can be hard. The Institute for Fiscal Studies, an economic research organisation speciali...
Nordens Chartered Accountant and Business Advisers | Strategic Business Planning | London | Essex | Award winning accountant
VAT: Reverse Charge For…
Are you CIS and VAT registered? If so, read on… From 1st October, the government is introducing the “VAT Domestic Reverse Charge” (also known simply as “Reverse Charge”) for businesses involved in building and construction s...
Nordens TV

We love making videos that break down convoluted accountancy jargon into a plain talking explanation of the important facts.

Nordens Chartered Accountant and Business Advisers | Strategic Business Planning | London | Essex | Award winning accountant
Preparing Management Accounts
Hi, I’m Mitch Hahn, Partner at Nordens Chartered Accountants. Today I am going to explain what Management Accounting is and how you can use it to help you become more successful. Welcome to Nordens TV! Management accounting ...
Nordens Chartered Accountant and Business Advisers | Strategic Business Planning | London | Essex | Award winning accountant
Management Accounting
Management Accounting is the process of preparing reports and accounts that provide accurate and timely financial and statistical information to help you make short-term and long-term decisions that enable your business to purs...
  Why I Founded Nordens

In November 2002, having sold our other business interests off earlier in the year, I decided to set up Nordens Chartered Accountants. The easy part was knowing how to do it, as I had established and built a smaller practice a few years earlier, the difficult part was not following the traditional accountancy path. Having run businesses, both successfully and unsuccessfully, I wanted to help business owners resolve their short term problems and work with them to achieve their longer term goals. Business has always been my interest and I love that I can help business owners achieve what seems like the impossible every single working day.

Mark Norden
Founder

We're Professionally Certified

Our limited company accountants have a range of qualifications from The Institute Of Chartered Accountants (ICAEW) to the Association of Chartered Certified Accountants (ACCA). They follow the bye-laws, regulations and ethical guidelines of the ACCA and we are an ACCA accredited employer. We are also accredited by Professional Passport for our Umbrella and accountancy services.